Did anyone catch the piece that aired on ABC’s Good Morning America yesterday (Gene Shopping: Parents Won’t Pass on Deadly Diseases with New Procedure)? For some parents the decision to test your embryos for diseases is difficult, but in the end they say it is the right thing to do for them and their families.
“I mean we go to church, you know. … We have family that, you know, was thinking that, that it was expensive,” Chad said. “I weighed the pros and cons of this and I couldn’t, I couldn’t pass that onto my daughter, knowingly.
“I have about an 80 to 85 percent chance of getting colon cancer. I get screened regularly. … I’m trying to combat it as best I can. I just want, like anybody does, I just wanted a healthy kid and not have to go through the worries that I go through.”
When confronted with the question of whether or not gene-shopping is ethical, many in the biotech industry respond with confindent assurance.
“I think there’s a big difference between choosing, selecting for eye color or height or athletic ability or appearance, and choosing for potentially, and in some cases, a certain lethal disease, like the genes for Huntington’s, for example,” Johnson said. “I think we’re capable, both professionally and societally, of making that distinction.”
“There’s a gray area in the middle where it’s going to be more difficult,” he continued. “But this kind of decision where you’re talking about preventing colon cancer, to me is very clear.”
I wrote a post last year (Biotechnology and the Church) in which I asserted that the church has dropped the ball on many of the bioethical issues that our society faces in the 21st century. We are no longer talking about aborting babies; we are simply talking about making better babies. There are many questions we need to ask ourselves in order to respond to the “ends justify the medical means mentality” of our culture.
The questions … raise[ed] for Christians are numerous. How does … [genetic testing of embryos] … relate to the Biblical vision of the New Heavens and New Earth and of the resurrected and glorified body? How does the biotech revolution relate to the vision of God to “restore all things to their rightful and more glorious place and function in Jesus Christ†and, derivitively, to the Commission of the Church? How does the biological/technological convergence/revolution relate to the call to “make disciples of Jesus Christ†(i.e. people whose lives conform more and more to the restored image of God’s perfections and righteousness in Jesus Christ)?
What do you think about the direction in which the biotech industry is moving, specifically with regard to gene-shopping? Are the issues black and white, or are there increasing shades of grey? How do you see your Biblical convictions shaping the debate on this and other social and cultural matters?